It Was Never a Dream. It Was a Policy. And They Repealed It.
By: Casey Cannady : nomad, cybersecurity veteran & Chapter 7 survivor
TL;DR
A. Mechele Dickerson, who holds the Arthur L. Moller Chair in Bankruptcy Law at UT Austin, went on The Daily Show to explain that the American middle class did not happen by accident. It was engineered, deliberately, through government policy coming out of the Great Depression, and over the last forty years that same government quietly unbuilt it. I filed Chapter 7 on October 15, 2025, and for almost thirty years I had believed the story that said a failure like that could only be my own fault. Her argument gave me a citation for what I had felt in my gut all along: my fall out of the middle class was not a moral event. It was a predictable output. And what was built on purpose can be rebuilt on purpose.
A. Mechele Dickerson went on The Daily Show to explain how America built its middle class on purpose, then took it apart the same way. I am what that looks like up close.
I filed Chapter 7 on October 15, 2025.
It did not come out of nowhere. It came at the end of a brutal stretch: almost seven years of corporate loyalty that ended over a cost-of-living adjustment they would not pay, then DOGE tearing through the contract economy I earned my living in, then tariffs shoving the price of ordinary life even higher. Any one of those, you survive. Stacked on top of each other with no raise underneath to absorb the blow, they are a flood, and I was standing in the lowest part of the room.
For a long time I carried that the way most people are trained to: as a verdict on me. Work harder, the story goes, make smarter choices, and the American Dream pays out. Don't, and you get exactly what you earned. I believed that story for almost thirty years. Then I watched a bankruptcy law professor calmly dismantle it on basic cable, and something I had felt in my gut for years finally had a citation.
Her name is A. Mechele Dickerson. She holds the Arthur L. Moller Chair in Bankruptcy Law at the University of Texas at Austin, and her new book is The Middle-Class New Deal. On The Daily Show she said the thing I had needed someone credentialed to say out loud: the American middle class did not happen by accident. It was engineered, deliberately, through government policy coming out of the Great Depression. And over the last forty years, that same government quietly unbuilt it.
Watch the full interview: A. Mechele Dickerson on The Daily Show
Read that twice, because it matters.
The middle class was a policy. Not a trophy for good behavior. A policy.
Which means my fall out of it was not a moral event. It was a predictable output.
The Promise I Was Sold
I spent nearly three decades in and around corporate America. I dropped out of Purdue and went to work at Radiant Systems in Atlanta.
I worked hard and climbed the ladder, moving to new opportunities whenever I had to in order to keep up with the rat race. My wife called me a workaholic. I called it doing what was asked of me in the hope of making myself indispensable. I did what you are supposed to do: I made myself useful, stayed loyal, and trusted that loyalty was a two-way contract.
It was not.
I left HCL Software after six-plus years because they would not give me a cost-of-living adjustment. Sit with how ordinary that is. Not a raise for heroics (despite having brought millions in revenue to the company). A COLA. The bare arithmetic of not getting quietly poorer every year while the rent and the groceries and the insurance premiums climbed. The answer was no. That “no” is a small thing and a whole thing at once, because it is the sound the old deal makes when it breaks: the company keeps the productivity, you keep the erosion.
Dickerson points at the disappearance of the pension job and stable homeownership as two of the tentpoles that used to hold a middle-class life upright. I did not read that in a book first. I lived the load-bearing wall coming out.
Not One Thing. Everything.
The line of hers that landed hardest was simple. The middle class is not suffering because of one thing. It is suffering because of everything, all at once.
That is the part the “personal responsibility” sermon can never account for, because the sermon needs a single villain (you) and a single fix (try harder). Real life is a stack:
- Wages that flatlined while the cost of staying alive did not.
- Housing that turned from the main way regular people built wealth into a thing you rent from someone wealthier. We downsized from 1,800 square feet on three acres in 2020 and hit the road full-time on December 30, 2022. Some of that was choice. Plenty of it was math.
- Healthcare that, in my case, became its own slow-motion bankruptcy long before the legal one (more on the medical-industrial complex in a future post, because that one deserves its own ring of hell).
- Credit as the duct tape over all of it. When the income will not cover the basics, the plastic does, until it can't.
None of these is the cause. The cause is the design that let all of them fail together while telling each of us we failed alone.
The Bankruptcy Professor and Me
Here is the part I keep turning over. Dickerson studies bankruptcy for a living. She maps, with data and footnotes, how working families end up funding their own survival with consumer credit until the floor gives way. I did not study it. I arrived at her conclusion from the other direction, with my name on the petition.
For months I treated that petition as the most shameful document I had ever signed. What she gave me, sitting across from Jon Stewart, was a reframe I could not argue with: when a system removes the supports it once guaranteed and then hands you a credit card to cover the gap, the bankruptcy is not your character showing. It is the policy working as redesigned.
I am not ashamed of Chapter 7. I am informed about it now. And informed, it turns out, is just a quieter word for furious.
Built on Purpose Means It Can Be Rebuilt on Purpose
This is where Dickerson refuses to leave you in the dark, and where I will follow her.
If the middle class was constructed by deliberate law and policy, then it is not a force of nature that has simply passed. It is a structure that can be built again, on purpose, with the same scale of ambition that built it the first time. New Deal scale. Housing, labor, education, and credit treated as load-bearing public choices instead of private moral tests. Jon Stewart called her ideas music to his ears. I'd call them a blueprint, and blueprints can be redrawn.
That is the difference between despair and fury. Despair says it's over and it's your fault. Fury says it was done to us on purpose, which means it can be undone on purpose, and I would like the people who did it to look us in the eye while we undo it.
Why I'm Telling You This
I am not a law professor. I am one guy who believed the rigged game was fair right up until it cashed me out. My story is one data point. But Dickerson's whole argument is that there are millions of us, and that calling it personal failure is how the people in charge keep us isolated and quiet.
So I'm being neither. If any of this sounds like your last few years too, you are not the broken part of a working system. You are the working part of a broken one.
Watch the interview. Read her book. And then get loud with me.
Source: A. Mechele Dickerson, The Middle-Class New Deal: Restoring Upward Mobility and the American Dream (UC Press, 2026), as discussed on The Daily Show with Jon Stewart.
Connect with Casey
If this resonated, or if there's a topic you want me to take on next, reach out. I read everything.
| Websites | |
| @cmcannady | |
| facebook.com/cmcannady | |
| Threads | @cmcannady |
| Bluesky | @cmcannady.bsky.social |
| linkedin.com/in/caseycannady | |
| X / Twitter | @casey_cannady |
| YouTube | @CaseyCannady |
Casey writes about economic policy, nomadic life, cybersecurity, and navigating the world as a late-diagnosed AuDHD adult. New posts drop on my professional website.