Back to Blog

They Didn't Take It From You. They Made It Too Expensive to Keep.

First in a new series: The Right to Own

By: Casey Cannady : nomad, cybersecurity veteran, Chapter 7 survivor & would-be American manufacturer

October 5, 2026
11 min read
Casey Michael Cannady
Right to OwnRight to RepairConsumer ProtectionTechnology

TL;DR

Lauren Fix at Car Coach Reports put out a video arguing that older cars are being quietly regulated off the road: fees, inspections, and restrictions stacked until a paid-off car costs about what a payment costs. She is right about the mechanism and right about the outcome. I think she is pointing at the wrong room. Sort her own evidence by certainty and the hard facts are not statehouses at all.

They are a $10 billion bid to merge two of the largest parts networks in the country, a $700 million private-equity purchase of Pep Boys, and the collapse of a supplier whose brands you have in your garage right now, which ended with Fram and Autolite selling for $25 million. Meanwhile the strongest evidence I could find about who actually extends the life of a product runs the other way: the phone in my pocket got two extra years because California passed a right-to-repair law. This is post one in a new series called The Right to Own, and the whole thing comes down to one test you can apply to any rule, any merger, and any product launch.

Nobody has to ban anything. They just have to make keeping it cost more than replacing it.


I am writing this on a laptop with a dead trackpad, in a ten-year-old travel trailer I have written about before.

That is not a bid for sympathy. It is the reporting.


What She Gets Right

The video is called “SECRETLY Banning Older Cars,” and I watched the whole thing before I disagreed with any of it.

The video this post is answering: Car Coach Reports, “SECRETLY Banning Older Cars”

Her framing device is a guy she calls Mike, in California's Central Valley. Paid off a 2008 Camry three years ago. 142,000 miles. Starts every morning. Last year's only real repair was a set of brake pads he installed himself in the driveway on a Saturday. Mike is not a collector and is not making a statement. He did the arithmetic and decided five more years out of a paid-off car beat a new payment.

Then the fees start stacking. Annual charges aimed at older model years. Inspections that dictate which brake components are acceptable. Smog costs that climb. And Mike works out that staying legal in the car he already owns is starting to cost about what a car payment costs.

Her core insight is the good one, and I want to quote her framing because it is the sentence the whole series hangs on. The net effect, she says, is not a formal prohibition. It is a quiet redefinition of ownership that turns a reliable paid-off car into a regulatory privilege.

That is exactly right, and it is not limited to cars. It is happening to your phone, your laptop, your tractor, your printer, and my house.

She also lands the strategic logic cleanly: you do not ask people, and you do not tell them. You arrange the economics so the outcome you wanted happens on its own and looks like a choice.

I have made a living for nearly 30 years watching systems quietly stop protecting the people using them. That is a real pattern and she named it.

Where I part company is on whose fingerprints are on it.


Sort Her Own Evidence and It Falls Into Two Piles

I went through the video and separated every claim by how certain it is. Try it yourself. The result is not subtle.

Pile one: signed, dated, dollar-denominated, and entirely private.

  • O'Reilly Automotive has made an unsolicited bid of roughly $10 billion for Genuine Parts Company's automotive division, the business that operates as NAPA. Bloomberg reported it on July 2, 2026. That unit booked over $15 billion in sales last year. GPC had already announced plans to split into two public companies in early 2027, with NAPA as one of them; O'Reilly moved to buy the whole thing outright instead. Neither company has publicly addressed the bid, and GPC is still proceeding with the split. Antitrust review is expected, because NAPA's network is the one that independent shops and people who fix their own cars actually depend on.
  • Mavis bought Pep Boys for approximately $700 million in cash. This is not a rumor. The stock purchase agreement was signed July 19, 2026, announced two days later, closed on August 20, and it is in Icahn Enterprises' SEC filings. It added nearly 800 locations and took Mavis past 4,400 service centers across the US and Canada. Mavis is private-equity backed and already owns Midas, Tire Kingdom, and Tuffy.
  • First Brands is gone. She mentioned it in passing. It deserves its own paragraph, below.

Pile two: her regulatory examples.

  • The California fees on pre-2007 vehicles: she says herself they are not statutes. They are proposals collecting cosponsors.
  • Minnesota's House File 3865, the collector-car restriction: it never received a single committee hearing. It died.
  • Massachusetts: the 2035 rule applies to sales of new cars, and she concedes it does not touch already-registered older vehicles.
  • Leno's Law: this is a smog exemption. It is deregulation, and I will come back to it because she got the details wrong in a way that helps her argument and hurts the truth.

She got the pattern right and the proportions backwards. Her hard evidence is corporate consolidation. Her villain is a legislature. The things that measurably reduced your ability to keep a paid-off car this year were an acquisition, a takeover bid, and a bankruptcy, and no elected official cast a vote on any of them.


The $25 Million Fire Sale

Here is the story she gave one sentence to, because it is the whole argument.

First Brands Group filed for Chapter 11 on September 28, 2025, in the Southern District of Texas. You have never heard of First Brands. You have absolutely heard of what it owned: Fram oil filters, Autolite spark plugs, Trico and ANCO wipers, Raybestos, Centric, StopTech, Cardone, Champion Laboratories. Roughly $5 billion in annual sales. Around 26,000 employees worldwide.

The company was assembled by acquisition and financed with off-balance-sheet debt. One creditor said roughly $2.3 billion had simply vanished, and the company's own restructuring counsel, asked where it went, said “We don't know.” On January 29, 2026, federal prosecutors unsealed an indictment of the founder and his brother on fraud charges, alleging falsified invoices and receivables pledged to two and three lenders at once.

Then the parts stopped.

Brake Parts Inc., Cardone, and Autolite were put into wind-down in January 2026. Champion Laboratories in Albion, Illinois, permanently closed on February 23, 2026, taking about 1,000 jobs with decades of tenure attached. Plants closed across Illinois, Ohio, Texas, and Tennessee. And in March 2026, twelve of those brands, including Fram, Autolite, and Trico, sold for $25 million up front, plus deferred payments and assumed liabilities.

Twenty-five million dollars. For the companies that make your oil filter and your spark plugs.

Nobody stopped needing spark plugs. Demand did not fall. A financial structure fell over, and the physical capacity to supply an entire category of routine maintenance parts got liquidated underneath it. Another aftermarket supplier, Premium Guard, has since bought the brands and the Albion filter lines and says it will reopen the plant with nearly 200 jobs. Rebuilding a factory takes years. Destroying one took a quarter.

No statehouse did that. No environmental regulation did that. That is what actually made it harder to keep an old car this year, and it is the exact same machine I wrote about in the grill brush piece: extraction runs the thing until quality is a cost, then leverage runs the company until the company is a cost.


Four Things in My House

I am not writing this from the sidelines. Everything I own is on somebody else's retirement schedule.

The 2020 F350. A modern diesel is a rolling emissions-and-electronics system, and the practical consequence is that many independent diesel shops will not touch a truck this new. Not because they lack the skill. Because the diagnostics and the emissions systems are locked behind manufacturer tooling and liability that a two-bay shop cannot carry. So the pool of people allowed to fix my truck shrinks toward the dealer, and the price goes where a shrinking pool of sellers always sends it.

The Pixel 7 Pro. Still running fine. It stops receiving security updates in October 2027. Nothing will be wrong with it. The hardware will work. It will simply become something I cannot responsibly use, which for a guy who has spent his career on endpoint security is not a hypothetical.

Karen's Surface. It runs Windows 11. In my humble opinion, Windows 11 and its successor are spyware with a start menu. If that reads as hyperbole from a guy who has spent nearly 30 years in IT and security, ask yourself why the Enterprise edition ships with telemetry controls the version on your kitchen table does not get. The answer is that organizations with lawyers negotiated for something you were never offered. So the plan is to wipe it and put Ubuntu on it with touch support configured, because Karen is already comfortable in Ubuntu. That machine gets a second life, and the only reason that option exists is that somebody built a free operating system nobody can revoke.

The Lenovo P51. The trackpad failed. Lenovo does not sell a trackpad. The trackpad is bonded into the upper case assembly, so replacing a failed pointing device means buying the palmrest, the keyboard bezel, the fingerprint reader, and the color sensor, all as one part. Lenovo part number 01HY708.

I went looking. Here is what the market has for me:

  • $119.95, for a rectangle of glass I need and four components I do not.
  • Not sold by Lenovo. It is a third-party marketplace listing, from a seller I have never heard of, under a brand that exists to supply parts the manufacturer will not.
  • Nine of them left in stock.
  • And when I put in my delivery address, I get told my location is beyond the seller's shipping coverage.

So the part does not exist as a part, and the assembly that contains it is scarce, and the one listing that has it will not ship to me. That is three separate walls for one failed input device on a mobile workstation that otherwise runs perfectly.

I am typing this on a wireless mouse with the trackpad disabled.

Sit with the arithmetic Lauren Fix runs on Mike's Camry, then run it on my laptop. A component the size of a playing card, which does not exist as a component, is doing to a workstation exactly what a brake pad rule does to a paid-off car. Not a ban. A bundle.


The Phone in My Pocket Proves the Sign Is Backwards

Here is the fact that made me rewrite this entire post.

My Pixel 7 Pro was not always going to get Android upgrades through October 2027. Google originally gave the Pixel 6 and 7 generation three years of OS upgrades and five years of security patches. In December 2024, Google extended OS updates for the Pixel 6, Pixel 7, and Pixel Fold by two additional years.

And the Pixel 8 and later get seven years of both. Reporting at the time tied that commitment in large part to California's right-to-repair law, which took effect that year.

Read that slowly.

The silicon did not change. The battery did not change. A legislature moved a number in a document and millions of devices got years of life added.

Your device's expiration date is not a property of the device. It is a setting, and it is currently set by whoever has the most people in the room where it gets typed.

Which means the frame “the government is coming for your old stuff” has the sign backwards on the one case where we can actually measure it. On phones, regulation is the only force that has ever pushed the expiration date out. Not competition. Not consumer preference. Not the market. A law.


Where She Is Right, and Where It Stops Being Abstract for Me

I am not going to pretend regulation is automatically on your side, because there is a live example that hits my own company directly.

New York has enacted a 3D printer blocking mandate as part of its 2026-2027 budget. It requires printers sold in the state to run a firearms blueprint detection algorithm and refuse to print flagged files, with penalties reaching $10,000 per violation. The Electronic Frontier Foundation and Adafruit both read the covered-device language as reaching far past hobby printers, into CNC mills and effectively any machine that shapes an object from a digital design file. California has since signed its own version, though it only takes effect if a technical standard for the blocking technology is ever published. Washington has proposed its own version.

The blocking technology does not exist. The statute knows it does not exist, which is why the mandate is deferred to 2029 or later pending a working group finding that it is technologically feasible.

Set aside what you think about the underlying firearms question. Look at what the machine is. A mandate that every fabrication device sold must screen your design file against a state-maintained library and refuse the job is not a rule about guns. It is a rule that establishes, as a design principle, that the tool decides whether you are allowed to make the thing.

My company, 3D Nomadic, exists to build homes on wheels using large-format 3D printing, on the premise that if a part breaks you reprint it. The entire pitch is that you own it all the way down and you can keep it alive. A legal architecture where fabrication equipment ships with a veto is a direct threat to that, and to every small shop that currently makes the discontinued bracket nobody stocks anymore.

She is right that this belongs in the same conversation as the parts counter. She reported it as roughly eighteen banned tools, and I could not verify that number or find where it comes from, so I am not repeating it. The actual laws are more specific and worse.


The Only Test That Matters

So if regulation added two years to my phone and also threatens the machine my company runs on, “more regulation” and “less regulation” are both useless as a position.

Here is the test I am going to use for the rest of this series, and I would like you to use it too.

Does this rule, this merger, or this product decision extend the usable life of the thing you already own, or shorten it?

Apply it and everything sorts itself immediately.

  • California right-to-repair, which put seven years of updates on a phone: extends.
  • Leno's Law, exempting rarely-driven collector cars from a smog test: extends.
  • New York's print-blocking mandate: shortens.
  • Parts pairing, so a trackpad is only sold welded to a palmrest: shortens.
  • Dealer-locked diagnostics on my truck: shortens.
  • Two of the largest parts networks in the country merging: shortens.
  • An oil filter manufacturer liquidated by financial engineering: shortens.

That test does not care about your politics. It cannot be spun, because it produces a number: how many more years does the thing work. And it exposes the actual score, which is that the shortening column is winning badly and almost none of it was voted on.


Showing Up Has Already Worked Twice This Year

I am not going to dump this on you and walk off, and this time I do not have a download for you, because the ask is not a PDF. It is your voice in a room.

Two proofs, both from the same twelve months, both in the video's own material.

Minnesota. House File 3865 would have restricted collector cars to daylight hours on weekends plus organized events. Owners noticed, organized, and showed up. The bill never received a single committee hearing. It did not get voted down. It never got heard.

California. She reported that “SB 712” is the live 2026 Leno's Law bill with a September 12 deadline. That is wrong, and the correction is the better story. SB 712 is dead; it passed the Senate 32-3 in June 2025, then was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file in August 2025. The live bill is SB 1392, Leno's Law 2.0, authored by Senator Dave Cortese, a Democrat from San Jose, with Senator Shannon Grove, a Republican from Bakersfield. It passed the Senate, cleared Assembly Transportation 13-0, and this August it cleared the same Assembly Appropriations Committee that killed last year's version. It is now law. The Assembly passed it on August 31, and Governor Newsom signed it on September 16, in Jay Leno's garage. The people who lost this fight in 2025 came back in 2026 and won it.

A bipartisan deregulatory bill, backed by owners and by SEMA, made it past the exact committee that buried it twelve months earlier. That did not happen because the political weather changed. It happened because the same people who lost last year came back.

So here is the ask, and it is the whole point of this post.

  • Find out what is moving in your state right now. Bill trackers are free and public. So are committee calendars. Ten minutes.
  • Call your state rep and your state senator, not just your congressman. Right to repair and right to own are being decided at the state level, and a state legislative office counts calls in single digits. You are not one of ten thousand. You are one of nine.
  • Say the two phrases out loud: right to repair and right to own. Ask them for a position. Ask them to back parts availability, repair documentation, and bans on parts pairing.
  • Show up to one committee hearing, or submit one written comment. Minnesota is proof that a small number of people who bother is enough to stop a bill from ever being heard.
  • Support the outfits already doing this work. Repair.org, iFixit, EFF, and SEMA are not all on the same team about everything, and I do not agree with all of them about everything. They are all currently pulling the same direction on this.

And the practical stuff for this week, because sandbags still keep your feet dry:

  • Buy the wear parts now. Filters, plugs, belts, sensors, brake components. Lauren's advice on this is correct and the First Brands collapse is the reason.
  • Before you buy anything, check whether the part you will eventually need is sold separately. If the trackpad only comes attached to half the laptop, that is the price, and you should know it before the purchase and not after.
  • Learn one open-source alternative. Ubuntu on a machine Microsoft has finished with is not a political statement. It is two more years.
  • Keep the paperwork. Whatever fails, the paper trail is the only leverage you will have.

Sandbags help you. They do not rebuild the levee. Only organized people do that, and this year they did it twice.


Why I'm Telling You This

Because the story you are meant to accept is that your stuff simply wore out and it is time to buy more.

It did not wear out. Mike's Camry starts every morning. My Pixel works. Karen's Surface works. The P51 works, minus a rectangle of glass I am not allowed to buy by itself. My truck runs, and the constraint is not the truck.

What is actually running out is permission. Permission to source a part, permission to hire the mechanic you want, permission to receive a security patch, permission to make a replacement bracket in your own garage. And the thing about permission is that it gets granted and revoked in rooms, and rooms have doors, and almost nobody goes through them.

Despair says this is just how things are now, everything is disposable, and you are a fool for expecting to keep anything. Fury says the expiration date is a setting, set by people who can be named and who are, for the most part, still in the room, and it can be set the other way. Despair buys the replacement. Fury calls the representative.

I would like to keep my truck, my phone, my wife's tablet, my laptop, and my house. None of that is nostalgia. It is a threat model.

So watch the video, apply the test, then get loud with me.


Sources & Further Reading

  • Car Coach Reports (Lauren Fix), “SECRETLY Banning Older Cars, Making Sure You Can NOT Afford to Keep Them!”, the source for the Mike framing, the fee-and-inspection mechanism, the regulatory-privilege line, the Minnesota HF 3865 account, and the wear-parts advice. Retold in my words with my disagreements noted.
  • O'Reilly and Genuine Parts: Bloomberg's July 2026 reporting on O'Reilly's roughly $10 billion cash bid for GPC's automotive division, as covered by Modern Distribution Management, Motor1, Autoblog, and Aftermarket Matters. GPC's planned separation of its automotive and industrial businesses was announced February 17, 2026, and reaffirmed for the first quarter of 2027 in its July and September 2026 updates.
  • Mavis and Pep Boys: the July 21, 2026 joint announcement, the Stock Purchase Agreement dated July 19, 2026, and the August 20, 2026 closing, as disclosed in Icahn Enterprises L.P.'s SEC filings.
  • First Brands Group: Chapter 11 filing of September 28, 2025 in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Texas, case 25-90399; the January 2026 wind-down announcement covering Brake Parts Inc., Cardone, and Autolite; the February 2026 closure of Champion Laboratories in Albion, Illinois; the March 2026 sale of twelve brands including Fram, Autolite, and Trico for $25 million; and the federal fraud indictment of the founder and his brother unsealed January 29, 2026; and Premium Guard's June 2026 purchase of the Albion filter lines. Reporting via Hagerty, Distribution Strategy Group, Modern Distribution Management, and Transport Topics.
  • Google Pixel support windows: Google's December 2024 extension of OS updates for the Pixel 6, Pixel 7, and Pixel Fold; the seven-year commitment beginning with the Pixel 8 and its reported relationship to California's right-to-repair law (SB 244, operative July 1, 2024); and the October 2027 end-of-life date for the Pixel 7 and 7 Pro.
  • New York 3D printer mandate: the blocking-technology provisions enacted in New York's 2026-2027 budget, and analysis from the Electronic Frontier Foundation and Adafruit on the scope of the covered-device language, plus PBS NewsHour's reporting on the 2029 feasibility deferral, and California AB 2047, signed September 26, 2026 (Chapter 461, Statutes of 2026).
  • Leno's Law: California SB 712 (2025), held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file and listed as dead by the California Air Resources Board; and SB 1392 (2026), authored by Sen. Dave Cortese and Sen. Shannon Grove, signed by Governor Newsom on September 16, 2026 (Chapter 245, Statutes of 2026), per the governor's office, the authors' offices, SEMA, and Hagerty.
  • Previously on this blog: “The Grill Brush That Explains the Whole Broken Economy”.

Sourcing note: Every corporate figure above was checked against the primary announcement, SEC filing, or court docket where one exists, not against the video. The Mavis and Pep Boys numbers come from the companies' own announcement and Icahn Enterprises' filing. The O'Reilly bid is reported by Bloomberg and has not been confirmed by either company; treat it as a reported bid, not a closed deal. Lauren Fix's claim that roughly eighteen tools have been banned could not be verified and is not repeated here. Her account of SB 712 as the live 2026 bill with a September 12 deadline is incorrect, and I have laid out the actual legislative history above. Her segment on salvage yard fires is not addressed in this post because I could not substantiate it, and I do not print things I cannot substantiate. The Windows 11 line is stated as my opinion and labeled as such, informed by nearly 30 years in IT and security; the underlying observation, that enterprise editions of Windows expose telemetry controls consumer editions do not, is a documented difference in Microsoft's own product tiers. The details about my own vehicles and devices are from my own household. I am not an attorney. Verify anything you plan to repeat.


Connect with Casey

If this resonated, or if there's a topic you want me to take on next, reach out. I read everything.

Casey writes about economic policy, nomadic life, cybersecurity, and navigating the world as a late-diagnosed AuDHD adult. New posts drop on my professional website.